To evaluate Ameristar Casino honestly, you need to understand the regional casino competitive landscape it operates in. The Midwest is arguably the most competitive regional gaming market in the United States — Missouri alone has 13 licensed casinos, Iowa has 19, and Colorado's mountain gaming towns pack multiple properties into a few square miles. In this environment, differentiation is everything, and Ameristar's strategy has consistently been to out-invest competitors on non-gaming amenities while maintaining a competitive gaming floor.
The gaming floor philosophy at Ameristar reflects a deliberate balance between volume and quality. With 2,400+ slot machines spread across five properties, Ameristar's slot density is high, but the mix skews toward newer machines with higher volatility profiles — a deliberate choice to attract recreational players who come for the excitement of big swings rather than the grind of low-volatility penny slots. The slot hold percentages at Ameristar properties are broadly in line with Missouri Gaming Commission reported averages, which hover around 8–10% for the state's casinos. That's not the loosest in the country, but it's honest for a full-service resort that's funding hotel towers and live entertainment.
Table game conditions deserve scrutiny from any serious player. Blackjack is the dominant table game, and the rules across Ameristar properties are mixed. The Kansas City and St. Charles properties offer 6-deck shoe games with 3:2 blackjack payouts on most tables — that's the correct standard — but 6:5 games do appear on some lower-minimum tables, particularly during high-traffic periods when the casino fills tables to meet demand. Always confirm the payout before sitting. Double-deck games with favorable rules (S17, DAS, RSA) appear occasionally but are not consistently available. Craps odds bets are typically capped at 3-4-5x, which is standard for the region.
The hotel product is where Ameristar genuinely separates itself from most regional competition. A $150/night room at Ameristar Kansas City includes amenities — pool access, fitness center, on-site dining options, entertainment venue proximity — that a comparable-priced urban hotel simply cannot match. The Amerispa is a legitimate full-service operation, not a hotel fitness-room afterthought, and the Star Pavilion entertainment schedule brings in acts that would otherwise require a trip to a major metro. For the regional entertainment dollar, the bundled value proposition is compelling.
The My Choice loyalty program, analyzed purely on economics, is a mid-tier performer among major US casino loyalty programs. It competes favorably with Penn Play (Penn Entertainment) and Marquee Rewards on earning rate and redemption flexibility, but falls short of Caesars Rewards' breadth of redemption partners and MGM Rewards' luxury property portfolio. For a player who visits primarily Midwest and Mountain West casinos, however, My Choice is arguably the most practical choice — the network of Boyd properties is dense enough that cross-property redemption has real-world utility, not just theoretical appeal.
One underappreciated aspect of the Ameristar experience is the consistency of service quality across properties. Boyd Gaming has invested in standardized training and service protocols that produce a noticeably more professional floor experience than many independent regional casinos. Dealers are generally skilled and courteous, beverage service is attentive on the gaming floor, and the players club staff are knowledgeable about the My Choice program's current promotions — a detail that matters because the promotions change frequently and the staff are your best real-time source of information.