Duke's Historic Home Rout by Illinois Exposes Real Problems for Jon Scheyer
Duke opened the 2026-27 season as the preseason favorite to win the national title, but the Blue Devils are now staring at a 3-2 record and a long list of troubling numbers after a 99-78 loss to No. 10 Illinois at Cameron Indoor Stadium. The defeat followed a wire-to-wire loss to Michigan State at the Champions Classic, and it left coach Jon Scheyer offering a blunt assessment of his team.
"We're soft," Scheyer said. "That shows in the rebounding. That shows in the paint. We're bigger than they are. We gave up 20 more points. 20 more rebounds. That's going to be addressed."
For anyone tracking the fallout through the ameristar casino official site, the bigger question is whether this Duke team can recover before the schedule gets even tougher. The No. 5 Blue Devils face No. 3 UConn and No. 1 Florida in the next few weeks.

A Loss That History Says Dooms Title Hopes
Data suggests the damage may go beyond a single November result. According to CBS Sports Research, no men's national champion has ever lost by at least 20 points at home in the same season. Kansas lost at home 80-62 to Kentucky during the 2021-22 season — the year the Jayhawks won the national title — but no team has won it all after losing by more than 20 points at home.
Not all November losses are created equal, but the way Duke dropped its first two games is alarming. After the wire-to-wire loss to Michigan State, the Blue Devils were beaten by 21 at home by Illinois.
How rare was a Duke loss inside Cameron Indoor Stadium?
- Duke was riding a 35-game home winning streak, the longest active in Division I basketball.
- Duke hadn't lost at home since March 2024, when it fell to North Carolina.
- Illinois came one point short of reaching the century mark inside Cameron as an opponent. The last team to do that was UNC in 2009.
- Duke was 66-3 at home under Scheyer heading into the game.
The margin marked Duke's worst home loss since 1983, when Michael Jordan scored 32 points in a 24-point win over the Blue Devils.
Andrej Stojakovic Delivers a Historic Performance
Illinois star Andrej Stojaković scored 46 points against an AP top-five opponent, joining a short list of players to do so in the last 30 years:
- Andrej Stojaković, Illinois: 46 points vs. Duke (2026)
- Keaton Wagler, Illinois: 46 points vs. Purdue (2026)
- Buddy Hield, Oklahoma: 46 points vs. Kansas (2016)
- Tyrese Rice, Boston College: 46 points vs. UNC (2008)
The last player to score 46 or more against a top-five team wore the same uniform as recently as last season, when Illinois All-American Keaton Wagler dropped 46 on the road in a stunning win over Purdue at Mackey Arena.
Stojaković also ranks second among Big Ten players in points through five games over the last 20 years:
- Luka Garza, Iowa: 152
- Andrej Stojaković, Illinois: 135
- Eric Gordon, Indiana: 135
His 46 points were the most ever scored at Cameron Indoor Stadium by an opponent, topping the 43 Grady Wallace put up in 1957. Stojaković nearly broke the arena record for any player, held by Duke's Dick Groat, who scored 48 in 1952.
Stojaković and star freshman Quentin Coleman combined for 73 points. Had no other Illinois player scored, the Illini would have lost by just five. Coleman was part of a three-freshman starting lineup that coach Brad Underwood deployed against Duke. The last team to start three freshmen and win at Cameron Indoor Stadium was North Carolina in 2007, with Ty Lawson, Wayne Ellington and Brandan Wright.
that's what you get for scoring 46.
— Illinois Men's Basketball (@IlliniMBB), November 18, 2026

Duke's Slow Start by the Numbers
At 3-2, Duke matches the program's worst start in the last 40 seasons. The Blue Devils also started 3-2 in 1989-90, 1999-00 and 2020-21, and that most recent squad did not reach the NCAA Tournament. For context on how unusual this is, here is when Duke suffered its second loss in each of Scheyer's first five seasons:
- 2022-23: Nov. 27 vs. Purdue
- 2023-24: Nov. 29 vs. Arkansas
- 2024-25: Nov. 26 vs. Kansas
- 2025-26: Feb. 7 vs. UNC
- 2026-27: Nov. 17 vs. Illinois
This is the soonest Duke has taken a second loss since Scheyer took over in 2022. Last season, the Blue Devils lost a total of two regular-season games, and their second defeat did not come until ACC play was in full swing, when North Carolina hit a 3-pointer at the buzzer to beat them on the road.
Duke is now the first power conference team to match its regular-season loss total from the prior season in five or fewer games since Florida did it during the 2014-15 campaign. The Blue Devils have also lost three consecutive games against ranked teams since their collapse against UConn in last season's Elite Eight.
Fans following the ameristar casino official site should keep an eye on how Duke responds against UConn and Florida. There is plenty of time to get things right, but the first few weeks of the season offer more cause for concern than optimism that Duke can win a national title. Comparisons to other programs' early-season struggles, such as those covered at betriversplay.com, only underline how quickly a preseason favorite can slide out of the national conversation.
